Miracle of the Sun

From time to time we are presented with those who would attempt we poor catholics just how stupid and superstitious we are. This is one of the more serious ones that is written by Brian Dunning in Skeptoid.

"...It's hard to argue with the facts of this event. The day was predicted in newspapers by a ten-year-old girl, and this is thoroughly proven. Tens of thousands of people personally witnessed exactly what the prediction said would happen. The sun's behavior was clearly unique, and couldn't have been mistaken for some chance atmospheric oddity. You add all this together, and the only reasonable conclusion is that Lucia Santos' vision and prediction was a genuine miracle.

Unless, of course, you set a reasonable standard for evidence, and start looking for things like alternate explanations. Let's point our skeptical eye at some of these details one by one, and see if they hold up to scrutiny. I'll start with the children's reports of six months of religious apparitions. These were three kids, ages 7 to 10, and came back home each night with wild tales. Is this surprising? Is the miraculous appearance of the Virgin Mary really the most probable explanation for stories told by small kids? The two youngest, Lucia's cousins, both died of influenza within a couple of years, but Lucia lived to the age of 97 and clung to her stories her entire life. Investigator Joe Nickell reports that Lucia's own mother said that she was "Nothing but a fake who is leading half the world astray." Friar Mario de Oliveira, who knew her well, described her as living in a "delirious world of infantile fantasies" and suffering from "religious hallucinations". There are alternate explanations for the children's stories, imagination and boredom being chief among them... more...

A causual look at the video above will dismiss many of the criticisms he delineates.

As was said of St Bernardette's miracle, "For those who do not believe, no explanation is possible. For those who believe, no explanation is necessary." Anon.


1 comment:

Peterman said...

The invasion of France and Italy by the Russians/Prussians did not need to occur. Had the popes from 1960 on simply listened to Sr.Lucia. Instead, the consecration was never made, only JP2's lame "consecration of the world" which wasn't what Our Lady specified.
Prophecy and chastisements are conditional of course but things don't look good at this point.